Skip to main content

A Real Pain in the Knee


Author: Alex Tomesch, MD

Peer-reviewer: Mark Hopkins, MD

Editor: Katie Dolbec, MD




15 year old female presents to the emergency department for right knee pain. Pain is worst with jumping and landing, but is present to a minor extent at rest. You get x-rays and they show this. 



Figure 1: Weight bearing x-ray of bilateral knees, provided by the author


  1. What is your diagnosis?

  2. What is your management in the ED?

  3. What is your disposition?

  4. Do you consult orthopaedics emergently?

  5. What is the management of this? 





  • See Answers Below - 





  1. What is your diagnosis?


Patient has a lesion of the distal epiphysis, located in the right lateral condyle. This diagnosis ended up being Osteochondritis Dissecans (OCD)


PEARL: Given the x-ray findings, you should consider the following differential In a young otherwise healthy individual: 

  • Osteochondritis Dissecans - benign

  • Chondroblastoma - benign

  • Clear cell chondroblastoma - malignant (aggressive)

  • Subchondral cyst - benign

  • Giant cell tumor - benign (aggressive locally)

  • Enchondroma - benign

  • Osteoblastoma - benign

  • Ewing Sarcoma - malignant (less likely as this is not well circumscribed)

  • Osteogenic Sarcoma - malignant (less likely as this is not well circumscribed)


  1. What is your management in the ED?


Discuss with the patient and parents the possibilities for this lesion as well as the plan for pain management. Arrange close outpatient follow up and MRI, if possible.


PEARL: MRI does not need to be done emergently as most of these lesions are benign. 

  1. What is your disposition?


Follow up with PCP to obtain further workup - starting with likely MRI. 


  1. Do you consult orthopaedics emergently?


No. However most of these patients will end up seeing orthopaedics once outpatient imaging is obtained. 


  1. What is the management of this? 


OCD lesion management is based on the stability of the lesion. The stability is based off of the DeSmitt Criteria: 


  • high-intensity signal beneath the OCD lesion

  • well-defined focal defect in the overlying articular cartilage

  • fracture of the overlying articular cartilage

  • subchondral cysts

If all four are present this indicates a very unstable lesion. Operative treatment is typically recommended for unstable lesions and skeletally mature individuals. This consists of a wide variety of interventions based on the individual's lesion. Non-operative management is typically reserved for those who do not meet these criteria and consists of activity modifications and immobilization. 




References: 


  1. Quatman CE, Quatman-Yates CC, Schmitt LC, Paterno MV. The clinical utility and diagnostic performance of MRI for identification and classification of knee osteochondritis dissecans. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2012;94(11):1036-1044. doi:10.2106/JBJS.K.00275

  2. Bauer KL, Polousky JD. Management of Osteochondritis Dissecans Lesions of the Knee, Elbow and Ankle. Clin Sports Med. 2017;36(3):469-487. doi:10.1016/j.csm.2017.02.005




Sign up here to receive our weekly cases

Want to write? Email us at orthoempearls@gmail.com

Instagram/Twitter: @orthoempearls

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Pop Goes the Knee

"Pop Goes the Knee" Author: Tyler Jackson, MD Peer-reviewer: Terese Whipple, MD Final editor: Alex Tomesch, MD

IMPORTANT: We have a new home!

  Thank you for following us on this journey, we are moving to a (hopefully) more accessible and functional website www.orthoempearls.com . There are new features including a random case generator, an archived library, and an image bank. Keep an eye out for new features and we plan to have merch for you all soon! The below logo is a sneak peak into what we have coming through the pipeline!  In the next few days, you will be redirected to the new website automatically. www.orthoempearls.com

The Mysterious Foot Pain

Author: BuMin Kong, MD; Susie Lee, BA Peer-Reviewer and Final Editor: Mark Hopkins, MD